Thursday, September 29, 2011

What the Fed Appears to be what in Reality Is Not

Why the Fed Appears to be What in Reality is Not

I want to make my readers aware from the start that here you will find a point of view that is controversial, but logical and above all true.  Here we do not subscribe to any political agenda nor do we want to be politically correct.  Simply we need to learn how badly we are misinformed and mislead by people we usually put in a pedestal.
Here is an example of an article I found in first places in Google written by an (Supposedly) and authority in the field. The analysis this professor gives to the public is not only naive, and infantile, but it shows that the Fed today as in the past still has a great deal of influence in our universities and colleges.  Professor Buchanan does not bother to illustrate us with a little bit of how the Federal Reserve was created.  I bet he doesn't know that in 1910 under the auspices of Senator Nelson Aldrich all the most important CEO's of the biggest banks in New York  went on a trip to Jekyll Island, Georgia and together drafted what in December 23, 1913 became the Federal Reserve.  What is wrong with that?  Nothing, except that these were the very people Senator Aldrich was supposed to bring under control with new monetary legislation.  To brake the grip of the Money Trust is what the New York banks were called in those days.  Instead he joined them and these thieves with ties caused the banking havoc of 1907 to scare the people into a Central Bank legislation.  This single action should demonstrate that the Fed is nothing more than a Cartel of bankers and to be more precise  the bankers of New York.  There is nothing Federal about the Fed, there is nothing in Reserve, and it is a system yes, but works for their benefit not the American people.  So here it is you have an organization that appears to be Federal and working for the government but in reality is not.  Ask if you have an opportunity to a Federal Reserve employee is he/she is a federal employee.  The answer is no.   There was great deception at work to make this pass by congress, but that another story.
Below am going to act as if I was with professor Buchanan to give a different point of view to his proclamations because in this article he is very enthusiastic about braking the myths of the Federal Reserve.
 How is Money Created? Debunking Some Myths About Recent Policies to Stabilize the Financial System and the Economy
By Neil H. Buchanan
The recent economic crisis in the United States has been so severe that we are now experiencing something that has happened only a few times in history: zero interest rates. In a phenomenon technically known as a "liquidity trap," the monetary authorities have pushed the interest rate that they control essentially as low as it can go, yet the economy still needs more stimulus.  Zero interest should not exist in a free market society.  No organization should control the interest rates, but the natural forces of supply and demand. It is because the Fed prints money out of thin air that they don't have to charge high interest rates to show a profit, you see.  They just don't want to kill the goose that lays the golden eggs.  Not yet.
The usual kick that we would experience from low interest rates is not being felt, because people are simply unwilling to spend in these difficult economic times. That was part of the argument for the stimulus package that was enacted in April, in which Congress and the President agreed on a two-year program to directly increase spending in an effort at least to slow the downward slide of economic activity.
Whether the stimulus bill is or is not effective (and, although I think it was too small, it is likely to play at least an important role in turning around the economy), some people have turned their criticism toward the Federal Reserve – commonly called the Fed, this country's central bank – saying that the Fed's creation of money to fight the crisis is threatening the country with long-term inflation, even hyperinflation.
These claims are not only overstated, but they often are based on a profound misunderstanding of how the financial system works. The danger is currently that the government is doing too little to fight the recession, not that the Fed is putting in motion an inflationary spiral. Understanding why this is so requires some basic knowledge about how money is created.  No kidding professor, Obviously you have no clue.
Money Out of Thin Air? The Myth that the Fed is Currently Doing Something Unusual and Dangerous
Modern financial systems are all based on money that is, in a very profound sense, created out of nothing other than group psychology. No one has any practical use for printed pieces of paper carrying portraits of dead presidents, yet everyone works to receive those pieces of paper. Why? Because everyone knows that everyone else will accept those pieces of paper in exchange for the things that we wish to own.
Fine piece of reasoning professor, but who gave the authority to the Fed to print money? and loan it to the government and charge interest on nothing? Why do you feel so oblivious about a group of men who through brilliant deception put a noose around the neck of the government and consequently the American people.  It would be okay if this paper belong to the US Treasury, instead it belongs to a group  of Bankers who have betrayed our trust over and over again.
The process of creating money is, however, more complicated than just printing pieces of paper that people will treat as money.
No it is not.  It starts in Congress when they want to fund their projects or wars and they don't have the money  together with the Treasury secretary they go to they Fed who has been waiting for them and ask for let's say 700 billion TARP money? So the officer at the Fed all he has to do is move his mouse around a little and with a few clicks.  Cashinga! the Fed just funded Congress with interest added of course. 
Most of the financial system, after all, carries out transactions in money that exists only in electronic form. Direct deposits of paychecks into bank accounts allows people to pay their bills online, which in turn allows merchants to pay their employees with yet more direct deposits (and some checks and cash).
Indeed, when we read about a company buying another company "with cash," that does not mean that millions or billions of dollars worth of greenbacks change hands. Typically, such a transaction is carried out in government IOU's known as Treasury Bills that, in fact, also never exist in printed form. Both sides to a transaction treat those securities as "cash" because they know that they can use them to buy things or trade them in for cash at some point.
The essential point to remember is that all of this is done with money that has been created out of nothing.
And you honestly believe that this is good for America.  Can you really say that our economy, our currency and our standard of living have improved from say 20 years or 40 years ago?  What sort of bubble or programing do you live in professor? 
The role of the Fed is to set up rules by which it can limit the amount of money (including both cash and non-cash forms of money) that is in existence. The Fed's methods of doing so are too technical to be of interest here.  Really?.  You're right, because if you try to understand what the Fed is up to from those bulletins about money allocations that they issue you will never get it. 
but the key point is that the Fed can create or destroy money by engaging in policy actions that are well-known and completely uncontroversial.
You're too much professor.  If they were destroying the money we wouldn't be paying  $6.75  for a hamburger instead of a dollar like back in the early 70's  and about uncontroversial.  You don't find controversial the fact that Paul Warburg who has been called the father of the Fed, had a brother Felix Warburg the chief of German Intelligence during WWI.  How about Ben Bernanke who admitted the Fed had a lot to do with the 1929 great depression.  You don't think that should be scrutinized!! 
The Fed – indeed, every central bank in the world – is constantly adjusting the amount of money that exists, generally as part of a strategy to set interest rates at a level that is projected to maximize growth with a low, stable rate of inflation.  Can you say that they have done a good job?
All of the money that exists today was, therefore, created by the Fed out of nothing at all. Even so, we are now hearing and reading urgent cries that the Fed is creating money "out of thin air," as if this is something horrible and dangerous.  I cannot believe you say this things with a straight face.  Just within the last six months, for example, the New York Times has carried nine articles which raise this specter. OMG, poor guys, I's obvious that you think it's okay that a bunch of unscrupulous bankers got a license to print money out of nothing, charge interest on nothing, have by now limitless resources to buy control over the government, politicians, and scholars in every institution including yours.
Even setting aside the two Times articles that were op-eds, regular Times news articles such as one from May 22 of this year have said quite bluntly: "The Federal Reserve is printing money from thin air." This is anything but objective language, and it is misleading at best.  I think it's you who is misleading professor; either by ignorance or by deception.
It is true that creating too much money can be dangerous, but the issue is not that money is being created from nothing, but rather that too much money can end up chasing too few goods.  Right!  That is clearly not the problem that we currently face.
Through the years the Fed has printed so much money that by now is practically worthless; and you don't think this is a problem we currently face? What have you been smoking professor? I bet you did some serious  LSD in Barkley
What About Gold? Why the Fed's Actions Would Be No Different if We Returned to the Gold Standard
Some readers might respond to the description above by saying that the problem is a different one: The Fed must be prevented from creating "fake money." What is "real money," then? Gold, of course!  This point, however, misunderstands the psychological nature of money, and it also mischaracterizes the true difference it would make if we were to take the radical (and completely unwise) step of returning to some kind of gold standard.
My Dear professor, in they days of my grandfather one once of gold was $20,00 and he could buy with that money a fine suit, a handcrafted belt and a pair of shoes. In the mid 1980's gold was about $320.00 an once and we could buy a fine suit, a handcrafted belt and a pair of shoes.  Today gold is about $1,200.00 an once and what can we buy, you guessed it, a fine suit, a handcrafted belt and a pair of shoes.  You see professor, the price of things don't change when expressed in terms of real money and not fake money like the Fed money.  Let that be a lesson to you professor.
If we wanted to limit the Fed's ability to manipulate the amount of such money that exists, we could simply link the amount of non-gold money to gold by some fixed multiple. However, doing so would have many undesirable consequences -- the most obvious being that our money supply would respond only to changes in the amount of gold in the world.  I think that is called supply and demand and that exist in a free market society.
The two countries with the largest known stocks of gold in the ground are Russia and South Africa, which means that those two countries could then increase or decrease the amount of our money by flooding the gold market or hoarding their stocks.  By the way.  Do you know where our gold is? Fort Knox is supposed to be the largest gold depository.  Do you know that no inventory has been made at Fort Knox since the days of President Eisenhower?  
In other words, even for those who yearn for a system in which the government has no ability to manipulate the amount of money that exists, the reality is that there is no such system.
Oh yes there is, let the government print the money as in the days of Abraham Lincoln and as recently as JFK when he issued EO-IIIO to abolish the Fed.  The reason is simple why pay an interest on money the Fed prints out of nothing when the constitution authorizes the government to do so.
The Real Issue: How Should the Fed Decide How Much Money to Create?
Perhaps the core concern of those who complain about the Fed's creating money "out of thin air" is really that the Fed is creating too much money too fast, not that it is creating money in an illegitimate way.
Oh yes professor, the Fed is illegal Constitution says so: Article 1 Section 8 to coin Money, regulate the Value thereof, and of foreign Coin, and fix the Standard of Weights and Measures.
The question, then, is how we would know when enough is enough.
No Professor, the question is how we get rid of this abomination:  as long as it persists in having advocates like you who dedicate themselves to keep the people in the dark.  You’re and your followers are nothing but mushrooms. You want to be kept in the dark and be fed B.S.
Attempts to find an answer to that question have filled economics journals for as long as there have been economics journals
And they will remain in attempts, as long they keep away from the truth.  Poor guys, they are like dogs chasing their tails.
That is not to say that there is no limit to how much money the Fed could or should create. Everyone agrees that if the Fed were to order the Government Printing Office to print up $100 trillion in new currency and distribute it to the public tomorrow, there would be massive hyperinflation. Raising that specter as a reason to criticize the Fed today, however, is like saying that the possibility of drowning means that one should never drink water, or swim, or bathe. That it is possible to create too much money does not mean that we should create none. 
But they have already done so, unless you've lived in Mars or were born yesterday.
If there is no reliable relationship between the amount of money that the Fed creates, within broad boundaries, and inflation, then what should the Fed do? Essentially, it should do exactly what it is doing right now.  As noted above, the Fed has pushed its policy-sensitive interest rate as low as possible, in an effort to stimulate economic activity.  You don't get it.  Do you?  Charging interest on nothing is very profitable considering the trillions of dollars.
This was completely sensible, given the extreme nature of the current crisis.
No, this a fraud and a scam my dear professor.  A Crisis by Design, that the Fed helped to create in the first place. Pick up some PBS videos and learn something for a change.  I cannot believe you as an intellectual can turn out to be such a useful idiot  for these crooks.
Unfortunately, the economy needed more stimulus.  Right, print more money, tax the American people via inflation and don't tell me that you don't understand this.  If your Ph. D. is worth a grain of salt you should know this. That is where the Fed's further actions came in, supplementing and enabling the actions by Congress and the President to try to create more economic activity directly.
Have you ever wondered why congress never has any problem with getting money and expends more than it collects from taxes? It's the relationship Congress-Fed.  Politicians don't need to ask the taxpayer for more money, they turn to the Fed.   As long as we continue this way we're doomed.
When the federal government needed money to finance various bailouts and the stimulus spending, the money had to come from somewhere. The alternative to continued borrowing from abroad was to have the Fed buy the federal debt that is being created, directly injecting new money into the system in an effort to stimulate spending.  Yes, new money with less value.
This strategy has its limits, of which the Fed is well aware. The current concern, however, has not been inflation but deflation, a decline in prices that can itself be a disastrous part of a decline into economic depression. The Fed wisely concluded, in short, that we should not worry about drowning when our most pressing problem is a severe drought.
The Fed was created as a lender of last resort and to keep the economy stable.  Why don’t you count how many times we have gone through these crisis since they took over and give them a report card.  Then, you will find that they deserve and "F".   There is nothing wise about the Fed, they are smart crooks I give you that much.
When the situation turns around, policy can and will change: We can create less money than we have been creating lately. That does not mean that the Fed will stop creating money out of thin air, but only that it is responding appropriately to changed circumstances. You mean another boom bust cycle.  Great hope.

Professor Neil H. Buchanan,   I leave you with the words of  Woodrow Wilson the President who signed this banking cartel into law.  I hope you reflect on it because is like Admiral Yamamoto's  reflection after his attack on Pearl Harbor  "I fear all we have done is to awaken a sleeping giant and fill him with a terrible resolve."
Here is Woodrow Wilson after signing the Fed into Law:
"I am a most unhappy man. I have unwittingly ruined my country. A great industrial nation is controlled by its system of credit. Our system of credit is concentrated. The growth of the nation, therefore, and all our activities are in the hands of a few men. We have come to be one of the worst ruled, one of the most completely controlled and dominated Governments in the civilized world no longer a Government by free opinion, no longer a Government by conviction and the vote of the majority, but a Government by the opinion and duress of a small group of dominant men." -Woodrow Wilson, after signing the Federal Reserve into existence.

If you want to know more information about today's economic crisis and who the authors are by name I recommend this book: Crisis by Design, by John Truman Wolf

http://crisisbydesign.net/?hop=mercury533

Neil H. Buchanan, J.D. Ph. D. (economics), is an Associate Professor at The George Washington University Law School, where he teaches tax law and policy.